In June 2020, a Stockton University student, Shelby Israel, faced public backlash after a photo surfaced showing her in blackface with a racial slur written on a sign. The image was reportedly taken in 2015 when she was a high school freshman. The revelation led to widespread calls for her expulsion from the university. However, Stockton University President Harvey Kesselman stated that, under university policy, they could not discipline Israel for actions committed before her enrollment, as they had no legal or administrative basis to do so. Despite this, the university condemned the behavior, acknowledging the harm caused and emphasizing its commitment to addressing racism and promoting understanding within the campus community. ​

In response to the incident, Israel issued a public apology, expressing regret for her past actions and committing to personal growth. She pledged to engage in community service and undergo sensitivity training as part of her efforts to make amends and demonstrate her commitment to positive change.

The university’s handling of the situation sparked debate about the balance between holding individuals accountable for past actions and providing opportunities for education and rehabilitation. While some advocated for expulsion, others supported the university’s approach, emphasizing the importance of education and personal growth in addressing issues of racism and discrimination.​

Stockton University reaffirmed its dedication to fostering an inclusive and respectful environment, stating its role as an institution devoted to learning and its commitment to addressing ignorance and prejudice through education and open dialogue